The discovery of an affair can feel like the ultimate betrayal in your relationship. Whether it was physical, emotional, or both, that betrayal can feel like the ground has fallen out from under you. The person you trusted most suddenly feels like a stranger.

Of course, then the questions start to come in. Do you stay? Do you leave? Can you ever trust that person again? Unfortunately, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer.

Affair recovery is deeply personal, and what’s right for one couple may not be right for another. As you give yourself time and space and decide what you want to do, you can make your decision with a confident, clear head.

That might sound easier said than done at first. So, how do you know when to stay or when to go?

Dealing with Emotions Immediately

After an affair comes to light, emotions are raw. You might swing from anger to sadness to numbness, sometimes all in the same hour. Your partner might feel guilty, defensive, or desperate to fix things. In this fog, it’s almost impossible to make a clear decision.

That’s why one of the first steps in working through things, no matter your final decision, is to take time to process things. Decisions made in the first days or weeks are often driven by shock or even fear, rather than reflection. By taking time and space to decide what you want, you’re more likely to feel better about your decision.

When Staying Might Be the Right Choice

Some couples do rebuild and stay together after an affair. In some cases, their relationship even grows stronger. However, staying only makes sense when there is genuine remorse. The unfaithful partner needs to take full responsibility, show consistent accountability, and make no excuses. They also have to be transparent. They should be willing to share things like phone access and open up to hard questions.

It also might be worth staying if both of you are committed to healing. Recovery is a two-way street. If both you and your partner are willing to put in the work, staying is often a possibility.

When Leaving Might Be the Healthier Option

Unfortunately, staying together isn’t always the best option. If you’re on the fence about what to do, leaving might be your best choice if your partner lacks accountability. If they’re minimizing, blaming, or gaslighting you into thinking it wasn’t a big deal, things likely aren’t going to get better.

If the affair continues, or it’s a repeated pattern, it also might be time to end things. Mistakes can happen. Repeated habits are hard to get rid of.

Ask yourself if your partner is truly willing to change. Can you really trust them again, even over time? Ask yourself why you want to stay. Is it out of fear, or genuine hope? What would you lose if you left, and what would you gain? There are so many questions to consider, which is why giving yourself time to work through them makes a difference.

Getting the Right Support

Affair recovery isn’t something you have to walk alone. Couples counseling can provide structure, while individual therapy offers space to process the grief and anger. A neutral third party can also help you spot patterns and make decisions without being clouded by guilt or fear.

An affair doesn’t have to be the end, but it can be. Only you can decide which path is healthiest for you.

Neither choice makes you weak. What matters is that your decision comes from a place of clarity and self-respect, not fear or pressure. Healing is possible, whether that’s together or apart. If you’re looking for support and guidance along the way, contact me for a consultation today.

Contact Me